August 28, 2014
1 min read

Is the premium surgeon still the captain of the ship?

You've successfully added to your alerts. You will receive an email when new content is published.

Click Here to Manage Email Alerts

We were unable to process your request. Please try again later. If you continue to have this issue please contact

With the mounting pressures of state and federal guidelines and the added burdens of local hospital and ambulatory surgery center bureaucracy, the question remains: Are premium surgeons still in charge in the OR setting?

The decisions on whether to use trypan blue to stain the anterior capsule, to use capsular tension rings/hooks in pseudoexfoliation cases or to open the extra viscoelastic tube to avoid endothelial trauma are all examples in play when trying to achieve the best outcome for our patients, but administrative pressures to keep costs down and be compliant with the “standard of care,” which varies to great degrees geographically, push the limits to keep us from going overboard as captain of the ship. Interestingly, there is a legal doctrine named “captain of the ship,” which holds that during an operation in an operating room, “[the] surgeon of record is liable for all actions conducted in the course of the operation.” This legal doctrine was coined in McConnell v. Williams in 1949 in which the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania ruled that “it can be readily understood that in the course of an operation in the operating room of a hospital, and until the surgeon leaves that room at the conclusion of the operation … he is in the same complete charge of those who are present and assisting him as in the captain of a ship over all on board, and that such supreme control is indeed essential in view of the high degree of protection to which an anesthetized, unconscious patient is entitled.”

Mitchell Jackson

Mitchell A. Jackson

Obviously, interpretation of this law can vary, but in reality, once that time-out is called, the surgeon is the captain of his or her ship until that case ends. Unlike commercial airlines that have a co-pilot who could take over in an emergency, most ophthalmology outpatient situations do not have a co-surgeon in the OR wing waiting in case of emergency. We must take all measures to be perfect from the start, and the adage that perfect practice makes for perfect results holds true.

Click here to read the full publication exclusive, The Premium Channel, by Mitchell A. Jackson, MD.