Women endocrinologists must ‘lead from where you stand’

Elaine M. Pelley
Elaine M. Pelley

Although women are underrepresented in leadership positions across medicine, those in endocrinology are seeing more opportunities as their numbers increase.

“As more women enter medicine, we are seeing pronounced gender segregation in specialty choice — some specialties are becoming female-predominant, while others continue to attract mostly men,” Elaine M. Pelley, MD, of the division of endocrinology, diabetes and metabolism at the University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, told Endocrine Today. “Endocrinology is on track to become the most female-predominant specialty of internal medicine.”

In a 2016 study assessing gender trends in endocrinology, published in The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism, Pelley and colleagues found that women in medicine hold fewer leadership positions, achieve less success in academia and are paid less than their male colleagues despite similar experience, number of hours worked and specialty choice.

Pelley said that many female physicians have approached her since publication.

“Like me, many of them perceived a completely level playing field as undergraduates and medical students and entered their medical careers with the outlook that gender bias was a thing of the past,” Pelley said. “Then, after spending 10 plus years working day and night, they look around and find that, despite all of their efforts, they are behind — in terms of leadership roles, academic advancement and, although it may not even be known to them, salary — the male peers they graduated with.”

Strategies for success

“This [realization] comes as a surprise, leaving many wondering what more they could have done,” Pelley said.

Women in medicine need to amplify one another, find their “posse,” request coaches and sponsors and craft their own legacy statements, according to an expert speaking during an AMA webinar in honor of Women in Medicine Month.

“Lead from where you stand, whether it be pediatricians addressing vaccination or emergency medicine physicians talking about disaster preparedness in a hurricane. Speak about the health impact of an issue,” Vineet Arora, MD, MAPP, from the University of Chicago said during the webinar. “Use your voice to promote medical truth. ... Celebrate the medical heroes among us.”

Arora kicked off the webinar by asking, where are the women in medicine who are leading? Though roughly half of applicants to medical school are women, only one in five women make full professor and just 16% rise to the level of dean of a medical school, she explained. This “leaky pipeline” fails women in medicine at that level, but that does not mean women in medicine are invisible or not leading. One-third of associate deans are women, but we do not hear about them, Arora said. Citing Julie K. Silver, MD, Arora discussed how even in medical press or lay press covering medicine, women are still missing.

Silver went on to show that women are underrepresented in benchmark areas of academia, such as award recipients of medical societies. The American Academy of Dermatology, Arora said, touts nearly half of practicing physicians as being women as well as faculty, yet one of their prestigious awards has only been given to women 8.3% of the time. In invitations to grand rounds, women are less likely to give those at other institutions and are less likely to be named visiting professors, Arora showed.

Coaches, sponsors

Arora attributed at least some of this to a discomfort among women – even women physicians – with self-promotion. In many cases, a physician must be sponsored for recognition like grand rounds and association awards and, in many cases, the best way to get that sponsorship is to ask for it.

“Many of us can find mentors in our workspace. It’s harder to find coaches and sponsors,” she said. “A coach is short-term interaction to help with targeted feedback and problem-solving. ... You need a sponsor to ... use their influence in their field to support their mentee to gain visibility.”

Coaches can help women work through job negotiations and sponsors can put names forward for Grand Rounds or society awards.

And once there, once recognized by an institution, women must also recognize the passive ways their roles can be minimized, Arora said. Specifically, she showed data in which women are introduced as “doctor” less often than their male peers. Though women introducers were on parity between the sexes, men introducing women called them doctor only 50% of the time while they did so for men being introduced 72% of the time.

“This could be a more subtle form of bias and you might think it’s not much,” Arora said. But it adds to the image of a doctor as a man. “Women are not perceived of not only as doctors but as leaders. ... We will see bias and we need to stand up in defense of our colleagues.”

Maternal, internal discrimination

Arora showed that this is compounded by “maternal discrimination” in the workplace where four out of five physician women reported discrimination and one-third reported discrimination based on being a mother. Pay discordance, consideration for promotion, disrespect by support staff and exclusion from administrative decisions were all heavily impacted by maternal discrimination, she showed. Additionally, women who reported maternal discrimination had 74% higher rate of burnout.

Lastly, Arora pointed to internal threats to women’s success – stereotype threat, the likeability penalty and imposter syndrome as well as women not supporting one another through Queen Bee syndrome – can further reinforce the lack of visible women leadership in medicine.

She cited medical school observation data where men scored 1.5 levels higher than women, which is equivalent to 4 months of additional training. The only correlation being the difference in sex, leading the researchers to hypothesize that this could be due to stereotype threat. Other research looking at critiques of medical residents’ performance showed mixed messages to women addressing their levels of confidence, assertiveness and aggressiveness.

Even the women quoted in her presentation, Arora said, often responded to her with statements playing down their leadership roles, yet they all very much lead from where they stand.

“The truth is that we are and we have to accept that and fight the internal voice in our head and go out and lead,” Arora said. “We all have to overcome this to lead.”

Amplification of women voices

She suggested women take on a role of amplification for one another. If each woman consistently gives credit to other women for the strides they’ve made, the research they’ve done or the stance they’ve taken, that amplification will be heard and cuts off the chance for someone else to take the credit. Instead, women are often seen to be each other’s worst enemies, with women bullies directing much of their antagonism toward other women.

“We have enough battles to fight that we have to work together and here’s this genius strategy we can operate on,” Arora said. “It’s important we step out from hiding and say, ‘I’m here and I’m ready to lead.’”

And, to do so, Arora says to women in medicine: “Find your posse.”

She belongs to Physician Moms, a Facebook group for physicians who are also mothers, and she said, “Social media has made it easier to find your posse.” These women along with those in the workplace and women in societies can act as a sounding board for physicians, allowing for confirmation and amplification of women in medicine.

Each woman in medicine should craft her own legacy statement, stand by it and find her support system to make it happen, Arora concluded. In this, you should create your image as a leader and set the goals that you want to achieve.

“This legacy statement centers you to think about what’s your compelling future and inspires you to change your present,” she said. “Think about your legacy because you are writing it every day.”

Healio.com has covered women in medicine for decades in various forms and these themes recur time and again. See the articles below for how things have changed and how women in medicine continue to fight similar battles to their predecessors. – by Katrina Altersitz with additional reporting by Amber Cox

2017

VIDEO: Expert reviews steps for women physicians to advance careers

“The focus of our discussion ... was really about encouraging [women and underrepresented individuals] that are earlier in their careers to really utilize those tools in order to gain the advantages of being able to become leaders in their field and to have greater satisfaction with their career and career development,” Norah Terrault, MD, MPH, said. Read More

Women face challenges, opportunities as roles change in endocrinology

“Endocrinology is definitely currently a women’s field, and it will probably stay that way for many years,” Pauline M. Camacho, MD, FACE, professor of medicine and director of the Osteoporosis and Metabolic Bone Disease Center at Loyola University Medical Center, president of the American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists and an Endocrine Today Editorial Board member, said in an interview. Read More

Women in endocrinology confront challenges, changes as influence grows

“We must engage and, I will dare to say, demand, institutional support,” Ann Danoff, MD, chief of medical service at the CPL Michael J. Crescenz VA Medical Center in Philadelphia, said. “There needs to be an openness to change, and an embracing of new viewpoints. There has to be transparency about how salaries are arrived at [and] how promotions are arrived at.” Read More

2016

Flexible work hours, clear boundaries key to work-life balance for rural women physicians

“A lack of women rural physicians especially limits access to care for women patients, who often prefer women clinicians and appear to complete more screening tests when seen by women,” Julie Phillips, MD, MPH, of the Michigan State College of Human Medicine, in Grand Rapids, and colleagues wrote. Read More

One-third of female physician–scientists report sexual harassment

“Even in a modern academic cohort of medical faculty, experiences with sexual harassment and discrimination are not uncommon, and they are more frequent among women,” Reshma Jagsi, MD, DPhil, associate professor and deputy chair of radiation oncology at University of Michigan Medical School, told HemOnc Today. “I do not think this is a castigation of academic medicine specifically. It is a sobering reminder of how far we have to go as a society. This is a broader issue.” Read More

Female physicians make 'substantially' less than male counterparts

“Fixing the pay gap between male and female physicians in academic medicine requires more than just studies showing that it exists; concerted efforts are needed to understand and eliminate the gap,” Vineet M. Arora, MD, MAPP, wrote in an accompanying commentary. “Fixing the gap will also require the courage and leadership of women academic physicians — the ‘Dr Lilly Ledbetters’ out there — to advocate to eliminate it. It is time that the ‘woman card’ be worth the same amount as the ‘man card.’” Read More

2015

Representation of women, minorities in physician workforce improving, still a long way to go

“Continued efforts are needed to increase the diversity of the physician workforce in the United States, particularly the specialties with the lowest representations of women, blacks, or Hispanics,” the researchers concluded. Read More

Study finds only modest improvements for women in academic medicine

“From our findings, we are concerned that there is complacency around the issues of women in academic medicine and a perception that gender issues have been addressed and are no longer a focus of attention,” the researchers wrote. Read More

2012

Female doctors’ pay lags behind men’s

“Maybe there are lessons to be learned from some other health care professions ... where gender differences are closer to zero,” John Appleby, PhD, chief economist at the King’s Fund, said. Read More

2010

National symposium focuses on increasing the number of women in surgical careers

“Lack of exposure means there are not role models for medical students interested in a career in orthopedics,” Lisa K. Cannada, MD, said. “Certainly, one cannot look for a female department chairperson of orthopedics and, if there are not women faculty in orthopedics who truly are role models and mentors, we cannot make an impact. For those female residents and orthopedic surgeons, the time is now to realize that any positive exposure and communication to women in medicine can make an impact. I encourage all women in orthopedics to take the time to make a difference.” Read More

1977

The Evolution of a Professional Support System for Women Physicians

In 1971 the women psychiatrists petitioned to become an official committee of the American Psychological Association district branch. The local psychiatric newsletter reported that “a goal will be to stimulate increased interest and participation on the part of women in their profession and in the society.” ... The meetings held in members’ homes have encouraged a social informality. Furthermore, they have permitted the women to see how their colleagues live and cope with problems common to all professional medical women. In addition, annual picnics - complete with spouses, lovers, and children - furthered the important social-support aspects of the group. Read More

Elaine M. Pelley
Elaine M. Pelley

Although women are underrepresented in leadership positions across medicine, those in endocrinology are seeing more opportunities as their numbers increase.

“As more women enter medicine, we are seeing pronounced gender segregation in specialty choice — some specialties are becoming female-predominant, while others continue to attract mostly men,” Elaine M. Pelley, MD, of the division of endocrinology, diabetes and metabolism at the University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, told Endocrine Today. “Endocrinology is on track to become the most female-predominant specialty of internal medicine.”

In a 2016 study assessing gender trends in endocrinology, published in The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism, Pelley and colleagues found that women in medicine hold fewer leadership positions, achieve less success in academia and are paid less than their male colleagues despite similar experience, number of hours worked and specialty choice.

Pelley said that many female physicians have approached her since publication.

“Like me, many of them perceived a completely level playing field as undergraduates and medical students and entered their medical careers with the outlook that gender bias was a thing of the past,” Pelley said. “Then, after spending 10 plus years working day and night, they look around and find that, despite all of their efforts, they are behind — in terms of leadership roles, academic advancement and, although it may not even be known to them, salary — the male peers they graduated with.”

Strategies for success

“This [realization] comes as a surprise, leaving many wondering what more they could have done,” Pelley said.

Women in medicine need to amplify one another, find their “posse,” request coaches and sponsors and craft their own legacy statements, according to an expert speaking during an AMA webinar in honor of Women in Medicine Month.

“Lead from where you stand, whether it be pediatricians addressing vaccination or emergency medicine physicians talking about disaster preparedness in a hurricane. Speak about the health impact of an issue,” Vineet Arora, MD, MAPP, from the University of Chicago said during the webinar. “Use your voice to promote medical truth. ... Celebrate the medical heroes among us.”

Arora kicked off the webinar by asking, where are the women in medicine who are leading? Though roughly half of applicants to medical school are women, only one in five women make full professor and just 16% rise to the level of dean of a medical school, she explained. This “leaky pipeline” fails women in medicine at that level, but that does not mean women in medicine are invisible or not leading. One-third of associate deans are women, but we do not hear about them, Arora said. Citing Julie K. Silver, MD, Arora discussed how even in medical press or lay press covering medicine, women are still missing.

PAGE BREAK

Silver went on to show that women are underrepresented in benchmark areas of academia, such as award recipients of medical societies. The American Academy of Dermatology, Arora said, touts nearly half of practicing physicians as being women as well as faculty, yet one of their prestigious awards has only been given to women 8.3% of the time. In invitations to grand rounds, women are less likely to give those at other institutions and are less likely to be named visiting professors, Arora showed.

Coaches, sponsors

Arora attributed at least some of this to a discomfort among women – even women physicians – with self-promotion. In many cases, a physician must be sponsored for recognition like grand rounds and association awards and, in many cases, the best way to get that sponsorship is to ask for it.

“Many of us can find mentors in our workspace. It’s harder to find coaches and sponsors,” she said. “A coach is short-term interaction to help with targeted feedback and problem-solving. ... You need a sponsor to ... use their influence in their field to support their mentee to gain visibility.”

Coaches can help women work through job negotiations and sponsors can put names forward for Grand Rounds or society awards.

And once there, once recognized by an institution, women must also recognize the passive ways their roles can be minimized, Arora said. Specifically, she showed data in which women are introduced as “doctor” less often than their male peers. Though women introducers were on parity between the sexes, men introducing women called them doctor only 50% of the time while they did so for men being introduced 72% of the time.

“This could be a more subtle form of bias and you might think it’s not much,” Arora said. But it adds to the image of a doctor as a man. “Women are not perceived of not only as doctors but as leaders. ... We will see bias and we need to stand up in defense of our colleagues.”

Maternal, internal discrimination

Arora showed that this is compounded by “maternal discrimination” in the workplace where four out of five physician women reported discrimination and one-third reported discrimination based on being a mother. Pay discordance, consideration for promotion, disrespect by support staff and exclusion from administrative decisions were all heavily impacted by maternal discrimination, she showed. Additionally, women who reported maternal discrimination had 74% higher rate of burnout.

PAGE BREAK

Lastly, Arora pointed to internal threats to women’s success – stereotype threat, the likeability penalty and imposter syndrome as well as women not supporting one another through Queen Bee syndrome – can further reinforce the lack of visible women leadership in medicine.

She cited medical school observation data where men scored 1.5 levels higher than women, which is equivalent to 4 months of additional training. The only correlation being the difference in sex, leading the researchers to hypothesize that this could be due to stereotype threat. Other research looking at critiques of medical residents’ performance showed mixed messages to women addressing their levels of confidence, assertiveness and aggressiveness.

Even the women quoted in her presentation, Arora said, often responded to her with statements playing down their leadership roles, yet they all very much lead from where they stand.

“The truth is that we are and we have to accept that and fight the internal voice in our head and go out and lead,” Arora said. “We all have to overcome this to lead.”

Amplification of women voices

She suggested women take on a role of amplification for one another. If each woman consistently gives credit to other women for the strides they’ve made, the research they’ve done or the stance they’ve taken, that amplification will be heard and cuts off the chance for someone else to take the credit. Instead, women are often seen to be each other’s worst enemies, with women bullies directing much of their antagonism toward other women.

“We have enough battles to fight that we have to work together and here’s this genius strategy we can operate on,” Arora said. “It’s important we step out from hiding and say, ‘I’m here and I’m ready to lead.’”

And, to do so, Arora says to women in medicine: “Find your posse.”

She belongs to Physician Moms, a Facebook group for physicians who are also mothers, and she said, “Social media has made it easier to find your posse.” These women along with those in the workplace and women in societies can act as a sounding board for physicians, allowing for confirmation and amplification of women in medicine.

Each woman in medicine should craft her own legacy statement, stand by it and find her support system to make it happen, Arora concluded. In this, you should create your image as a leader and set the goals that you want to achieve.

PAGE BREAK

“This legacy statement centers you to think about what’s your compelling future and inspires you to change your present,” she said. “Think about your legacy because you are writing it every day.”

Healio.com has covered women in medicine for decades in various forms and these themes recur time and again. See the articles below for how things have changed and how women in medicine continue to fight similar battles to their predecessors. – by Katrina Altersitz with additional reporting by Amber Cox

2017

VIDEO: Expert reviews steps for women physicians to advance careers

“The focus of our discussion ... was really about encouraging [women and underrepresented individuals] that are earlier in their careers to really utilize those tools in order to gain the advantages of being able to become leaders in their field and to have greater satisfaction with their career and career development,” Norah Terrault, MD, MPH, said. Read More

Women face challenges, opportunities as roles change in endocrinology

“Endocrinology is definitely currently a women’s field, and it will probably stay that way for many years,” Pauline M. Camacho, MD, FACE, professor of medicine and director of the Osteoporosis and Metabolic Bone Disease Center at Loyola University Medical Center, president of the American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists and an Endocrine Today Editorial Board member, said in an interview. Read More

Women in endocrinology confront challenges, changes as influence grows

“We must engage and, I will dare to say, demand, institutional support,” Ann Danoff, MD, chief of medical service at the CPL Michael J. Crescenz VA Medical Center in Philadelphia, said. “There needs to be an openness to change, and an embracing of new viewpoints. There has to be transparency about how salaries are arrived at [and] how promotions are arrived at.” Read More

2016

Flexible work hours, clear boundaries key to work-life balance for rural women physicians

“A lack of women rural physicians especially limits access to care for women patients, who often prefer women clinicians and appear to complete more screening tests when seen by women,” Julie Phillips, MD, MPH, of the Michigan State College of Human Medicine, in Grand Rapids, and colleagues wrote. Read More

One-third of female physician–scientists report sexual harassment

“Even in a modern academic cohort of medical faculty, experiences with sexual harassment and discrimination are not uncommon, and they are more frequent among women,” Reshma Jagsi, MD, DPhil, associate professor and deputy chair of radiation oncology at University of Michigan Medical School, told HemOnc Today. “I do not think this is a castigation of academic medicine specifically. It is a sobering reminder of how far we have to go as a society. This is a broader issue.” Read More

PAGE BREAK

Female physicians make 'substantially' less than male counterparts

“Fixing the pay gap between male and female physicians in academic medicine requires more than just studies showing that it exists; concerted efforts are needed to understand and eliminate the gap,” Vineet M. Arora, MD, MAPP, wrote in an accompanying commentary. “Fixing the gap will also require the courage and leadership of women academic physicians — the ‘Dr Lilly Ledbetters’ out there — to advocate to eliminate it. It is time that the ‘woman card’ be worth the same amount as the ‘man card.’” Read More

2015

Representation of women, minorities in physician workforce improving, still a long way to go

“Continued efforts are needed to increase the diversity of the physician workforce in the United States, particularly the specialties with the lowest representations of women, blacks, or Hispanics,” the researchers concluded. Read More

Study finds only modest improvements for women in academic medicine

“From our findings, we are concerned that there is complacency around the issues of women in academic medicine and a perception that gender issues have been addressed and are no longer a focus of attention,” the researchers wrote. Read More

2012

Female doctors’ pay lags behind men’s

“Maybe there are lessons to be learned from some other health care professions ... where gender differences are closer to zero,” John Appleby, PhD, chief economist at the King’s Fund, said. Read More

2010

National symposium focuses on increasing the number of women in surgical careers

“Lack of exposure means there are not role models for medical students interested in a career in orthopedics,” Lisa K. Cannada, MD, said. “Certainly, one cannot look for a female department chairperson of orthopedics and, if there are not women faculty in orthopedics who truly are role models and mentors, we cannot make an impact. For those female residents and orthopedic surgeons, the time is now to realize that any positive exposure and communication to women in medicine can make an impact. I encourage all women in orthopedics to take the time to make a difference.” Read More

1977

The Evolution of a Professional Support System for Women Physicians

In 1971 the women psychiatrists petitioned to become an official committee of the American Psychological Association district branch. The local psychiatric newsletter reported that “a goal will be to stimulate increased interest and participation on the part of women in their profession and in the society.” ... The meetings held in members’ homes have encouraged a social informality. Furthermore, they have permitted the women to see how their colleagues live and cope with problems common to all professional medical women. In addition, annual picnics - complete with spouses, lovers, and children - furthered the important social-support aspects of the group. Read More