Ambulatory Feedback System Improved Trunk Sway Gait Asymmetry

  • O&P Business News, Fall 2012

Trunk sway and gait asymmetry improved among individuals with transtibial amputations who used a lower extremity ambulatory feedback system, according to a study published in Gait & Posture.

“We’ve been working with sound sensors in shoes to come up with a way to measure how patients with transtibial amputations are walking without being in a motion analysis lab so we can look at them moving in their own home environment,” Stacy J. Morris Bamberg, ScD, assistant professor of the department of mechanical engineering at the University of Utah, told O&P Business News. “We decided to build this system where we put the sensors in the shoes to measure how the person was walking in real time and give feedback through a computer. We did this study because we wanted to find out if changing the gait is something that amputees are able to do if we give them feedback.”

Improvements in gait, symmetry

Three transtibial amputees with gait asymmetry from the University of Utah Rehabilitation Program used a gait asymmetry detection system called the lower extremity ambulatory feedback system (LEAFS) for six 30-minute training sessions over 3 weeks. Patients also performed a pre- and post-test in a clinical motion analysis lab one week before and after training.

LEAFS improved at least one of the outcome measures of gait asymmetry determined by the motion analysis lab in two of the three patients. Trunk sway was reduced in one patient by 85.5% and by 16% in the other patient while symmetry ratio increased toward unity by 26.5%, according to the study. Researchers found no improvements in gait symmetry or trunk sway in the third patient.

“The two patients that improved didn’t have a lot of health issues before their amputation. It was due to an infection, while the patient who had a hard time using the device had an amputation due to emboli in both legs. She only had one leg amputated, but her other leg still had some residual issues,” Bamberg, president of Veristride, which produces and sells the detection system, said. “Now our hypothesis is that using our device will be straightforward for people who have had an amputation due to trauma because that other limb is still relatively intact, so they’ll be able to use the feedback and quickly make a change in how they walk.”

Bamberg and colleagues hope that when patients go to physical therapy appointments, their physical therapist will help them set realistic goals to work on during the time until their next appointment. By setting the goals on the LEAFS program, the patient could use it independently to work on improving their gait.

“Our goal is that patients wouldn’t necessarily use our device forever, but they would use it until they get back to a symmetrical gait and are comfortable walking,” Bamberg said. “It wouldn’t replace physical therapy appointments, but be in conjunction and perhaps cut down on the number of appointments.” If perfect symmetry isn’t the goal for a patient with a high level knee amputation, for example, “maybe we can get them to a little bit more symmetry so they’re unloading their intact knee and decreasing the risk for osteoarthritis.”

Updates in the device

After the initial study, Bamberg and colleagues performed a second study to further improve the LEAFS system and insole sensor system. Twelve participants with no abnormal gait installed the sensor system into their shoes and used the adaptive, real-time instrumentation system for tread imbalance correction to perform several walking tests to assess the system’s ability to influence gait.

Participants walked normally down a 200-foot hallway while the system stored gait data to use as a control. Then they walked three separate times, each with a different sensory feedback method: visual, audible or vibrotactile. Participants received feedback from the system through an Android-platform smartphone that would induce gait asymmetry. At the end of all three walks, participants filled out a survey about which feedback method they preferred.

Researchers found that the visual feedback was successful in modulating the normal gait of all participants. Vibrotactile feedback also induced a statistically significant variance in gait, but study results showed audible feedback did not. Participants expressed that they preferred the visual feedback system over vibrotactile and audible.

“This system has potential for use in the rehabilitation and training of subjects who have undergone lower limb amputations, suffered from a stroke or who have Parkinson’s disease. In this way, it can serve as a supplemental rehabilitation method for use both in the clinic, and as a personal assistive health care device,” the researchers concluded. “To further develop this device, we will initially focus on further developing the auditory and vibrotactile feedback options, along with optimizing the power requirements, and shrinking the size of the associated electronics. Our next step is to use [the device] in a larger study, to investigate its effects on persons with gait abnormalities. We are particularly interested in assisting persons with lower limb amputations to regain symmetric gait.” — by Casey Murphy

For more information:

Redd CB, Bamberg SJM. A wireless sensory feedback device for real-time gait feedback and training. IEEE ASME Trans Mechatron. 2012;17:425-433.

Yang L, Dyer PS, Carson RJ, et al. Utilization of a lower extremity ambulatory feedback system to reduce gait asymmetry in transtibial amputation gait. Gait Posture. 2012;36:631-634.

Disclosure: Bamberg is president of Veristride.

Perspective
  • This article reports a pilot study on three transtibial amputees investigating a low cost device (LEAFS) to measure gait symmetry. Gait symmetry is important for a host of reasons ranging from cosmesis to prevention of falls and onset of early osteoarthritis. The study demonstrates the efficacy of the device in terms of functionality, although further research is needed to determine the ability of the LEAFS unit as part of an interventional strategy to improve symmetry in amputees or other patient populations (eg, stroke or cerebral palsy).

    The chief importance of the current research is the development of a relatively simple, low-cost, easily wearable device which has been validated for accuracy and repeatability in a movement analysis laboratory. One of the unique aspects, which will no doubt become commonplace in a short time and also factor into the cost minimization, is the use of a smartphone to record results and give user feedback in the most current version. The availability of such a device opens new venues of both therapeutic techniques to improve gait symmetry and research into these endeavors. It also streamlines the process for the user so that this device could potentially be used for home therapy. The user would simply don the device in their shoe and monitor their gait via a phone app, as is currently done with heart monitors that utilize phone apps.

    • Bruce MacWilliams, , PhD
    • Director, Movement Analysis Laboratory, Shriners Hospitals
      for Children, Salt Lake City, Utah
  • Disclosures:MacWilliams had no relevant financial disclosures.

Comments

Healio is intended for health care provider use and all comments will be posted at the discretion of the editors. We reserve the right not to post any comments with unsolicited information about medical devices or other products. At no time will Healio be used for medical advice to patients.